Wed
14 Nov 2007
3:59 pm
The Treadmill Desk: Exercise for the Sake of Hacking
Posted by shimon under computers/human-computer interaction , shimon , society/tech/gadgets[27] Comments
I work at my computer all day long. Between eight and fourteen hours on the average workday, I’m staring at a screen and typing on a keyboard. Until recently, this meant I didn’t get much exercise; I’d aspire to a bike ride on the weekends, but went most weeks with nothing more than a walk or two. This is compounded because I work from home — no trips to the water cooler and copy machine for me. If I wanted to, I could get by with about 100 steps of walking per day, between my bedroom, office, kitchen, and bathroom.
Then I started using a treadmill desk. The idea, originated by Mayo Clinic Researcher James Levine, is straightforward: instead of sitting at your desk, you work at a treadmill that’s equipped with a monitor, keyboard, and phone. Rather than sitting, you walk at a slow pace. Because the human body has evolved to walk long distances, a healthy person can comfortably walk several miles a day. After just a few days, I was consistently walking about 6 or 7 hours a day. It’s been about a month now, and I’ve used the treadmill desk every day I’ve worked from home.
I love it. And what’s really amazing it that I’m not just doing something healthy without taking time away from work. I’m working better because of the steady supply of exercise. My concentration is sharper and my energy level remains steady throughout the day. The exercise has made me a better hacker.
The magnitude of this result surprised me. I’m in decent shape; I wouldn’t mind losing a few pounds, but I eat well and my cholesterol and blood pressure are fine. On the other hand, I’m always looking for ways to be smarter or more energetic. Like many people whose work is intellectual, I suffer from lulls and funks, from afternoons of carb-induced catatonia to full days of hacker’s block. The exercise smooths over these funks. I still have some slow days, of course, but by defaulting to constant exercise, there’s a tremendous countervailing influence to the biochemical tides of mood.
How-to
If you think a treadmill desk might be good for you, it’s not hard to try it out. I started with a standing-desk
prototype (pictured at right): tray tables piled with books to bring my laptop screen and an external mouse/keyboard to eye- and hand-level, respectively. A standing desk has most of the exercise benefit of a treadmill, with the caveat that standing still is far more stressful to your joints and muscles than slow walking. You can try this with stuff you already have; if you like the exercise but are limited to only a couple of hours of continuous standing before your knees start to ache, it’s time to take the dive and buy a treadmill.
1. Get a Treadmill
My current treadmill is a HealthRider SoftStrider I got for $100 via Craigslist. When I wear this thing out, I’ll consider buying a new treadmill in the $1000 range, but a cheap used treadmill is a great starting point and craigslist is a good way to find some locally. You can transport a foldable treadmill in the back of a van/wagon, or, as I did, in a car trunk with some bungee cords and careful driving. (They’re really heavy; you’ll need a friend to help you navigate any stairs.) Key features of a desk treadmill are:
- Electronic. The force required to propel an un-powered treadmill will get in the way of your work. You need a conveyor belt under your feet. Give up on the dream of powering your computer with your footsteps.
- Slow speeds. You’ll want to control your walking speed in, at most, 0.1mph increments between 0.7 and 1.5mph. You don’t need a treadmill designed for running, but a padded belt will make the walk more comfortable and gentler. If you’re over 180lbs, double-check the treadmill’s capacity. Although you’ll only be walking, the continuous usage could potentially wear down a weaker platform.
- Update 1/27/2008: I would like to revoke my endorsement of padded belts. Foam doesn’t stay flexible forever and my belt has been gradually turning into dust. Most newer treadmills have a flat belt and cushioning under the deck, which is a better design.
- Level arms. All treadmills have arms that the occupant is supposed to hold while walking. Your hands, however, will be on the keyboard, which will be on a shelf. The easiest way to build this shelf is to attach it to the treadmill’s arms. And if the arms are angled, you’ll need to compensate for that in the shelf. If they’re level, you can just slap a board across.
- Update 1/27/2008: Actually, a level tray is not as good as one that’s inclined away from you. Ideally, you want to avoid bending your wrists, and you want to have your elbows open at 100 to 120 degrees. I’m still working on a design that achieves this; my temporary solution is a shim under the near end of my keyboard.
- Quiet. Old, underpowered, or poorly cared-for treadmills may hum constantly; try to find one that doesn’t make much motor noise. The noise of your footsteps and the belt’s motion on the deck will always be present, and on a nice newer treadmill these should overshadow noise from the motor itself. (Added 1/27/2008.)
- Console. Mounted on the treadmill will be an electronic console where you can set the speed. Sometimes these consoles include a reading tray and cup holder. You probably won’t want to use these for holding your monitor; vibrations in the treadmill will cause your monitor to shake and make it hard to read. So pick a console that is reasonably out of the way; you’ll need to at least build a shelf over it.
2. Build Some Stuff
Once you’ve got the treadmill, you’ll need to build two shelves: one for the keyboard/mouse, and another for your monitor and other equipment. The easiest way to do the keyboard tray is by attaching it to the treadmill’s handles, if they’re level. For mine, I have a wooden board that is laid across the handles, with segments of 2×4 on the sides in order to raise the shelf’s height. You’ll want to have the keyboard positioned so you can rest your hands on it with your elbows at an angle around 100 degrees. Since your body will be moving, you might also want a trackball instead of a normal mouse; being able to rest part of your hand on the shelf will stabilize your finger movements, and without that stabilization precise mouse movements will be difficult. I attached the keyboard shelf to the treadmill’s handles using industrial-strength velcro. This provides a solid attachment but allows me to lift the tray off of the treadmill so that I can fold the treadmill up, clearing space in my office for the fold-out guest bed.
The monitor shelf is different. You definitely want to avoid resting the monitor on your treadmill in any way, or vibrations from walking will shake your screen. Measure the height you’ll want in order to hold the screen’s center a level 2 feet in front of your eyes while standing on the treadmill. My shelf is at about 60″ from the ground (I’m 6’2″). My shelf has two legs (cut from 2x4s) and is held together with shelf braces; the materials and wood cutting cost around $25 total from Home Depot. A simpler design would be to build the shelf like a three-legged stool, with equal-length legs at the front left, front right, and rear center of the shelf. You might also be able to use a pre-made modular shelf, although it could be hard to find one that can straddle a treadmill.
3. Set Up Your Computer
You probably don’t want to force yourself to use the treadmill whenever you need the computer. A desk is useful if you get tired, or if you need to do actual paperwork — writing steadily is almost impossible on the treadmill. So I maintain my old desk, with its own monitor, keyboard, and mouse. These are connected to the same computer — the treadmill’s peripherals are connected via USB. While on the treadmill, I rotate the desk monitor and use it as a secondary screen — I leave work chat running there so I can see if anyone mentions my name, but drag the window over to the treadmill monitor for any intensive reading.
4. Brag About It
The treadmill desk is a great story for coworkers and friends. If you’ve read this far, then you’re exactly the kind of person I’d love to tell it to. In any social setting, the treadmill gives you an excuse to stand up, extend your arms, and walk around like a zombie while talking about what a geek you are. Lots of people find the idea appealing and will ask interesting questions.
The wikipedia Treadmill Desk page has more information. And, in case you’re wondering — this article was written entirely while walking.
Full Entries RSS
November 15th, 2007 at 3:19 am
very paleo:
http://www.arthurdevany.com/evolutionary_fitness/
November 15th, 2007 at 6:39 am
[...] shimon placed an interesting blog post on The Treadmill Desk: Exercise for the Sake of Hacking.Here’s a brief overview:I’m in decent shape; I wouldn’t mind losing a few pounds, but I eat well and my cholesterol and blood pressure are fine. On the other hand, I’m always looking for ways to be smarter or more energetic. Like many people whose work is … [...]
November 16th, 2007 at 11:43 am
Very cool! One of my first thoughts was that while walking, the rest of one’s body is naturally bouncing around a little bit, albeit gently. Do you find that it is any more difficult to focus on the text on your monitor with your head bobbing up and down slightly? Or that your typing is affected by the walking motion?
-bj
November 16th, 2007 at 12:12 pm
bj:
No, the body motion of walking doesn’t seem to impair my ability to read text on a stationary monitor. The human vision systems are very adaptable to motion; consider how well we can read signs while driving. I wouldn’t be surprised if there was some degradation of reading speed relative to sitting, but it’s probably on the order of 1-3%. Not enough to overcome the benefits of increased blood flow.
Actually, there is one stunning cognitive effect I’ve noticed. If I look at the monitor and step onto the treadbelt while the treadmill is stopped, I experience a feeling of moving rhythmically toward and away from the screen for a couple of seconds. This must be a conditioned response to the challenge of watching a static monitor while walking; the variation in distance might be more of a visual/cognitive challenge than the bouncing up and down. In any case, the effect is temporary and I’ve only noticed it a few times.
-shimon
November 19th, 2007 at 1:45 pm
You know, I always wondered how feasible this would be. At the gym, I usually use the eliptical machines while watching TV and wouldn’t mind having one at home that I could use while working on web stuff rather than sit in a chair all day.
So, what about weight loss? Notice any of that as a benefit, not so much?
November 19th, 2007 at 4:03 pm
Patrick:
My weight hasn’t changed but I think I’ve gotten slightly skinnier. I now often wear my belt one notch tighter than I did before.
If I were really aiming to lose weight, I’d have to also make sure to restrict my eating, which I haven’t done. The aerobic exercise does seem to curtail my snacking tendencies, although I may well be eating more at meals because of the increased exercise.
If you’re the kind of person who would lose weight by adding several miles of walking to your workday, then this would probably help you lose weight.
shimon.
November 30th, 2007 at 3:27 pm
Here’s an interesting study that suggests sitting for long periods is just plain bad for you. The technical abstract:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=17827399&ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum
and an ABCnews story:
http://abcnews.go.com/print?id=3922069
Thanks to Jim and Toby for the pointers.
December 1st, 2007 at 9:58 am
[...] The treadmill desk Shimon Rura has a great article talking about how he set up a treadmill desk. I read my NetNewsWire on the treadmill in the morning, but I’ve never looked at trying to type. I’ll have to see if I can improvise something around this. [...]
December 5th, 2007 at 4:12 pm
[...] Original post by shimon [...]
January 27th, 2008 at 12:57 pm
[...] That’s just a fun discussion question, with a few good stories in the responses. My answer, still kinda computer-related, is that time in high school that my friends and I built a computer lab so we could study Computer Science AP. (Although my treadmill desk and simulation of a door using a paperclip also came to mind.) [...]
March 14th, 2008 at 11:02 am
That’s a great setup Shimon.
I have done something similar to this, but I set it up to play videogames, believe it or not. Early this decade I became addicted to the PS2, but I also needed to spend time with my wife and then-newborn son, AND I needed to get in my workouts. So what better way than combine two things I enjoy?
What I do is set the TV on a high platform, like this site suggests. These days I actually have a 22″ LCD monitor that works great with an XBox 360, so having it set up high isn’t a problem. I set the treadmill at the highest incline of 10, and set the speed at 4 MPH. It’s at just the highest intensity I can actually play something and enjoy it, yet I’m still getting a good workout. I usually alternate between 60 and 90 minutes a day, 5 days a week, first thing in the morning. I satisfy my gaming “Jones”, I get great cardio, and my time is free the rest of the day for work, time with family, etc. I also lift weights immediately afterward 3 days a week, but nothing too intense, just to keep fit.
It takes some getting used to, but after a week or so you totally adjust. Give it a shot sometime. It makes the boredom of cardio on a treadmill fly by!
April 23rd, 2008 at 1:30 pm
If you don’t want to build your own (like I did) I came across a pretty interesting alternative that says it will be a lot less expensive than the WalkStation. It is called TrekDesk and it is pretty cool I think. You can read about it at http://www.trekdesk.com. It even has an exercise ball chair for those moments when you just cant walk and work at the same time.
July 4th, 2008 at 2:33 pm
never seen anythink like that.
http://www.homefitnessmovers.com
July 8th, 2008 at 8:44 pm
This is awesome, and I actually found it while Googling for “sake of” (for a puzzle I’m making, too complicated to explain) and finding it as the 33rd hit. Clicked through when I saw your name. Awesome to run into this, consider it Delicioused!
August 21st, 2008 at 4:20 pm
Hello,
I found you when I was looking for photos of other people who created their own treadmill
workstation desk.
I would like to show your treadmill on my site http://treadmill-workstation.com.
I will of course link back to you.
Thanks
October 27th, 2008 at 4:17 pm
[...] Have you ever seen cats on a treadmill? Well, these neuroscientists did that for a monkey, and then hooked the monkey brain to a robot in Japan on a treadmill, then shut off the monkey’s treadmill. The robot kept walking, taking steps toward our impending doom. [...]
January 1st, 2009 at 10:52 pm
[...] a week ago the treadmill I use in my treadmill desk — a Nordic Track A2350 — wouldn’t start. The display turned on and read [...]
March 24th, 2009 at 12:18 pm
What a great idea! I drag my laptop around the house, from desk to couch to dining room table working while I eat. I don’t gain weight, but that is just my metabolism. Nevertheless, I do get quite lethargic in the afternoons. I can’t do without a nap. This sounds like a great way to toss aside the nap for productive time.
I added this page to the resource page on my Treadmill website.
July 28th, 2010 at 8:04 am
My Dad does this. He likes to read at the same. I wish I had a treadmill so I could do the same.
September 5th, 2010 at 9:11 pm
[...] I need to do something like Shimon Rura‘s treadmill hack to make the time spent on it even more productive. Most probably I would [...]
September 27th, 2010 at 10:40 am
I built a setup similar to this, but put a shelf on the wall for my laptop. I’m hoping to lose some weight walking and working each day. I was surprised to find out that I can think through complex problem solving while on my treadmill (I’m a analyst\programmer). I wrote a blog post about it:
http://walkerdeskranger.com/the-treadmill-desk-and-complex-work-or-creative-thinking.html
Good luck to all those treadmill desking out there! I wrote this comment on my treadmill.
October 2nd, 2010 at 3:32 am
Nice setup shimon. Stand-up and treadmill desks definitely intrigue me, but based on my little experiments it’s very hard to concentrate after roughly 15 minutes of standing, as the discomfort starts to kick in. Because of this I’ve been skeptic of the benefits for things like programming and heavier reading such as math, which require a relaxed state of mind, I find.
After reading your blog post and that of Walker Desk Ranger, however, my hopes are renewed. Looking back, do you think it’s the treadmill that makes all the difference or did you also get good results with a simple stand-up desk?
October 3rd, 2010 at 4:03 pm
öbloink: You do have to be comfortable, I think. It took me a few weeks to get really used to the treadmill desk, and I still often prefer to sit during periods of deep thinking or reading. I did start off with a simple standing desk, and I liked it, although my knees definitely got uncomfortable pretty fast. Walking was more tiring at first, but once I got used to it I found it more comfortable and more energizing.
February 10th, 2011 at 9:34 pm
Really cool that you are using a treadmill desk machine. People spend far too many hours at a desk and the optimal number of hours walking or exercise everyday should be 2-4.
March 1st, 2011 at 9:21 pm
Very exciting. I note that you’re still using it after…what… almost 3 years, and possibly 3.3 now. Hmmm, must be working for you.
March 10th, 2011 at 8:20 pm
Hi Shimon, I just started today my first experiment of treadmill desk and I’m just excited. I was getting all sorts of problems to my legs (circulation, etc.) by sitting many hours at my desk. And I’m “only” 40.
I was wondering if after 3 years you are still using it and what were your results in terms of health and fitness.
Don’t you think a Recline like this ( http://www.technogym.com/it/prodotti/allenamento-cardiovascolare/cyclette/excite-+/recline/2706 ) would be better for concentration, though?
April 22nd, 2011 at 11:25 am
[...] Blogger Shimon Rura corroborates the idea of increased productivity; he says he concentrates better and gets more done when he’s standing (he actually uses a walking desk; his blog has instructions on how to build your own). [...]